What early users asked about our anonymous email relay — and what shipped since
On 25 October 2026 we posted a plain description of MingList to r/SideProject — including an honest list of what the site doesn't have: no user verification, no in-app chat, no payments, and most cities near-empty. The thread drew 18 comments, and several of them turned into concrete changes. This page records what was asked, what has shipped since, and what has not. It is a changelog in question-and-answer form, not a testimonials page; the questions are paraphrased and the original thread is linked for anyone who wants the exact wording.
“Doesn't Craigslist already do this?”
Yes — Craigslist has offered anonymous reply forwarding for decades, and the thread's top comment said exactly that. That comment is also a fair summary of why the model is worth building at all: it has proven itself at scale for longer than most current alternatives have existed. MingList is a smaller, modern take on the same idea.
A reply underneath made the sharper point: anonymous inbound is only half the problem. Most people blow their own cover the moment they hit reply from their normal email address. MingList's relay covers both directions. Each listing gets its own relay address, incoming replies are forwarded to your real inbox, and your reply goes back out through the relay — so the buyer never sees your address at any point in the conversation. The mechanics are written up step by step in how to post classifieds without sharing your email.
“What happens to the relay once the item is sold?”
Shipped. Each listing owns its relay address, and closing or removing a listing disables only that listing's relay — your other listings keep theirs. If a listing expires naturally instead, the relay stays live for a short grace window of about seven days, so replies already in flight still land, and then it stops. In other words: once an item is sold and taken down, its reply path is done. The address on the old page stops forwarding instead of sitting there as a scraping target.
“Can I set my display name once and reuse it?”
Shipped. Two people in the thread raised the same suggestion within a day of each other, which was convincing enough. You set a display name once, and the posting form prefills it for future listings; you can still edit it per post. It remains the only public name attached to anything you publish — MingList never substitutes your Google account name, and the only name other users can ever see is the one you typed yourself.
“What stops scammers from abusing the relay?”
Partly shipped, partly not — this question deserves the honest answer.
- Shipped: one-click reporting. Every listing has a report button, and reports go into a human review queue.
- Shipped: posting rate limits. Posting is capped per account, per IP address, and site-wide, which makes mass-creating listings expensive for an abuser.
- Shipped: sign-in requirement. Posting needs a one-tap Google sign-in, which stops most drive-by bot listing creation.
- Not shipped: scam-pattern detection. One comment made the sharpest point in the thread: a relay makes your domain the trusted sender of every message, including scam ones — a fake-payment email arriving from a real domain looks more legitimate than one from a random address. Automatic flagging of common scam patterns (overpayment offers, “my shipper will collect”, gift-card scripts) does not exist on MingList yet. It is on the list. Until it exists, the report button and ordinary caution are the real defences — the safety page covers what we do and don't promise.
“What is it built with?”
The front end and back end are hand-built. The relay runs on Cloudflare Email Routing and Workers: incoming mail is matched to its listing, forwarded to the seller's real inbox, and replies are routed back out under the relay address with custom Worker logic. No third-party messaging service sits between buyer and seller.
The honest list, as of November 2026
The same list the original post carried, updated where things have moved:
- Most of the 24 cities are still near-empty — a listing here may take longer to find a buyer than on a large marketplace, and posting in both places is the sensible move (our comparison of Craigslist alternatives covers the bigger boards).
- There is no user verification, no in-app chat, and no payments of any kind; meetings and payment are arranged the old way.
- Scam-pattern detection is not implemented (see above).
- What has moved: relay expiry after a listing is closed, reusable display names, the report button, and layered rate limits all shipped between October and November 2026.
If you want to see how the current flow works, browse a city — no account needed to look. And if you want to check what happened to the classifieds platforms everyone used ten years ago, the platform status tracker keeps a dated record.
FAQ
How does the MingList email relay work?
Each listing gets its own relay address, which is what appears on the page. Replies sent to that address are forwarded to the seller's real inbox, and the seller's reply goes back out through the relay. Neither side ever sees the other's email address, at any point in the conversation.
What happens to the relay address when a listing is sold or removed?
Closing or removing a listing disables only that listing's relay; the seller's other listings keep theirs. If a listing expires naturally, the relay stays live for a grace window of about seven days so replies already in flight still arrive, then it stops. After that, the address on the old page no longer forwards anything.
Do I have to type my display name every time I post?
No. You set a display name once and the posting form prefills it for future listings; you can still edit it per post. It is the only public name MingList shows to other users, and your Google account name is never substituted for it.
How do I report a suspicious listing or message on MingList?
Every listing has a report button. Reports go into a human review queue rather than an automated filter. Posting is also rate-limited per account, per IP address, and site-wide, which makes bulk abuse expensive.
Does MingList automatically filter scam messages?
Not yet — and we would rather say so than imply otherwise. Automatic detection of common scam patterns such as overpayment offers or shipping-agent scripts is not implemented as of November 2026. It is planned. Until then, the report button, the in-person meeting guidance on our safety page, and ordinary caution are the available defences.
No account to browse or reply. Your email is never shown. Every reply reaches you through MingList's anonymous email relay. Free to post, free to browse.